frontpage hit counter

Archive for the 'research' Category

Personas - to do or not to do

Friday, October 24th, 2008

Where I work we occasionally create personas as a deliverable. The problem is sometimes it’s fabricated, sometimes, it’s based on marketing data, and sometimes it’s based on design research. Personas are a tool like anything else in a UX designer’s toolkit. It may or may not be the right tool for the project but the danger of distributing them without real research is it can derail the project and have the client holding on to archetypes that aren’t real.

Elizabeth Bacon and Steve Calde presented these slides at Catalyze webinar on July 23, 2008. They’re a great summary of why, when, how to use personas.


Why Designers Fail

Tuesday, October 21st, 2008

Scott Berkun conducted a survey surrounding the topic of

“why designers and people who work with designers believe designers don’t achieve the results they desire”

His top findings:

The 389 survey respondents self identified as:

Designer 33.7%
Project manager 16.5%
Programmer / Tester 11.8%
Usability engineer 9.5%
Group manager 6.9%
Business / Marketing 3.9%
Documentation 1.3%
Other 16.5%


The top 15 issues, ranked by average scores were:

People in non-design roles making design decisions 4.18
Managers making design decisions w/o design training 4.14
Designers don’t seek enough data before designing 3.92
No time is provided for long term thinking 3.81
Not receptive to critical feedback 3.69
Lack of awareness of the business fundamentals 3.66
Only lip-service is paid to “User centered design” 3.64
It’s never made safe to fail or experiment 3.62
Designer’s power diluted by too many cooks 3.60
Over-reliance on one kind of design style 3.54
Poor collaboration skills 3.51
Poor persuasion / idea pitching skills 3.49
Poor communication skills 3.49
Poor understanding of domain 3.48
Pressure to use first solution, not a good solution 3.45
Big Ego / Expects others to cater to their whims 3.41

More summary and breakdown of the results here

Primer on Ethnographic research and Interviewing

Wednesday, July 30th, 2008

Two students from IIT went ahead and defined what ethnographic research is and how to conduct it. It was a great refresher for me. Thanks to Todd Warfel for originally posting this on his site.



Getting People to Talk: An Ethnography & Interviewing Primer from Gabe & Kristy